← Back to blog

How to Choose a Tax Preparer for Your Small Business

November 21, 2026
How to Choose a Tax Preparer for Your Small Business

The right tax preparer for a small business is someone who reviews your income and expenses line by line, explains the finished return in plain English before you sign, and puts their name and PTIN on it. If you run a one-person business, freelance or drive for a gig app in Auburndale or anywhere in Polk County, you also want someone who agrees on the scope and the fee before work starts. At Sally Sam Ventures, Samuel prepares returns for freelancers, gig workers and self-employed filers in person or online, and small-business returns are prepared once scope and fees are confirmed. This guide shows how to judge any preparer, step by step.

Sallysamventures
sallysamventures.com
Get Support With Small Business Taxes
Sally Sam Ventures prepares personalized tax returns for small business owners, freelancers and gig workers in Auburndale and Polk County, in person or online.
Visit

TL;DR

  • A good preparer checks your records, finds the deductions and credits you qualify for, and walks you through the return before you authorize filing.
  • CPAs, enrolled agents and attorneys can represent you before the IRS. Preparers with only a PTIN cannot.
  • Fees should be agreed in advance and tied to the work, never to a percentage of your refund.
  • Never sign a blank or incomplete return, and make sure your refund goes to your own bank account.
  • Bring organized records. Cleaner records mean a faster, more accurate return.

Table of Contents

What a tax preparer does for a small business

The IRS says a tax professional can advise a small business on how it is structured, look over its books and records to help make sure income is reported and deductions and credits are claimed, and answer questions about excise taxes and employment tax returns. A qualified professional may also be able to represent you before the IRS, and an experienced one can help you avoid tax scams.

For most small owners, the day-to-day reality is simpler than that list. If you are a sole proprietor, you report your business income and expenses on Schedule C of your personal return. If your net earnings from self-employment come to $400 or more, you also figure self-employment tax on Schedule SE. Nobody withholds tax from your payments the way an employer does with a paycheck, so you may owe estimated tax payments during the year.

That is where a preparer earns the fee. The work is not typing numbers into boxes. It is sorting what counts as income, what counts as a business expense, what belongs on a personal return and what you are missing. If you also have a W-2 job on the side of your business, the preparer ties both together on one return.

What a tax preparer does for a small business

Which credential should your preparer hold?

Anyone paid to prepare a federal return must have a PTIN, a Preparer Tax Identification Number. That number alone says nothing about training. The IRS explains the credential differences this way:

Type of preparerHow they qualifyRepresentation before the IRS
Enrolled agent (EA)Licensed by the IRS, passes a three-part exam, completes 72 hours of continuing education every 3 yearsUnlimited
CPALicensed by a state board of accountancy after the Uniform CPA Examination plus education, experience and character requirementsUnlimited
AttorneyLicensed by a state court or barUnlimited
Annual Filing Season Program participantCompletes an IRS-recognized continuing education programLimited to clients whose returns they prepared and signed
PTIN onlyRegisters with the IRSNone

Why this matters: roughly 56% of the more than 684,000 preparers registered with the IRS at the start of 2026 were non-credentialed, according to a 2026 mystery-shopping report from the Taxpayer Rights Education Project. The same report found returns from non-credentialed preparers accounted for over 94% of dollar adjustments in earned income tax credit audits for tax year 2021. A credential is not the only sign of quality, but it tells you how to check someone and what happens if the IRS writes to you later.

The IRS also notes that preparers who do not appear in its directory may still provide quality service, but you should ask about their education and training. Ask plainly: how long have you prepared returns, what training do you complete each year, and how many returns like mine have you done?

Match the preparer to your kind of business

A W-2 employee with a simple return and a freelancer with three income streams do not need the same conversation. Before you hire, describe your situation in one paragraph and see whether the preparer asks sensible follow-up questions.

If you are a W-2 employee. Your employer already reported your wages. The value of a preparer is making sure credits, family circumstances and any side income are handled correctly. Our W-2 tax preparation covers income review, deduction and credit review, and an explanation of the finished return.

If you are a freelancer, gig worker or self-employed. Your records are your return. Mileage, supplies, software, a home office, platform payouts and 1099 forms all need to be sorted before anything is filed. Missing expenses cost you money, and invented ones put you at risk.

If you own a small business. The structure of the business drives which forms apply. A good preparer asks how the business is organized, whether you have employees and whether you have other owners before quoting a fee. We prepare small-business returns after confirming scope and fees, so you know what is covered before the work begins.

Tax preparer considerations for four client situations

If you want to handle it all remotely. A busy family or owner may never want to sit in an office. Virtual tax preparation gives you the same review and the same explanation of your return without the drive.

Verify before you share your financial information

The IRS puts the burden on you: you are responsible for everything on your return no matter who prepares it, so the agency's guidance for small businesses centers on verification. Run through these checks before you hand over a Social Security number.

  1. Look them up. The IRS keeps a public Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers listing attorneys, CPAs, enrolled agents and Annual Filing Season Program participants. You can also verify an enrolled agent's status on IRS.gov.
  2. Check their history. Look for complaints or disciplinary actions. Fairfax County's consumer guidance points to state boards of accountancy for CPAs, state bars for attorneys and the IRS Office of Enrollment for enrolled agents.
  3. Confirm e-file. The IRS says most refunds come in under 21 days for e-filers with direct deposit and a complete, accurate return, as noted in its quick tips for picking a tax pro.
  4. Ask about year-round availability. The IRS advises choosing someone with a track record, because a preparer may need to answer questions about your return months or years later.
  5. Ask how your data is protected. New York's tax department suggests asking how sensitive data is safeguarded and how many people can access your files. It is a fair question anywhere.

Arizona's revenue department adds a few more worth asking: what formal training the preparer has, whether they will explain how the return was prepared if it is examined, and whether you get a copy of the completed return.

What tax preparation costs and what moves the price

There is no single going rate. The 2026 mystery-shopping report found estimated or actual fees ranging from $60 to $800 across 53 test visits. The spread reflects what is being prepared: a basic W-2 return sits at one end, while a return with business income, many expense categories and several forms sits higher.

Three things move the fee:

  • Complexity. More income sources, more forms and more records to review mean more time.
  • Scope. Whether the work covers only your return or also a business return, and whether it includes explaining the result.
  • Condition of your records. Organized receipts and statements shorten the job.

Our fees are based on your filing needs and the complexity of the return, and they are agreed before preparation begins. That is the standard you should hold any preparer to. The IRS says to ask about service fees up front and to avoid preparers who base fees on a percentage of your refund. New York's tax department adds that fees should relate to the services provided, not the size of the refund.

Red flags that should end the conversation

Federal and state agencies list the same warning signs. Walk away from a preparer who:

  • Will not sign the return or leaves off their PTIN. The IRS says every paid preparer must sign and include a 9-digit PTIN.
  • Asks you to sign a blank or incomplete return.
  • Wants your refund deposited into their account. The IRS says to check that the routing and account numbers on the completed return are your own.
  • Promises a big refund before looking at your information or suggests a deduction or credit that does not apply to you, as New York warns.
  • Accepts a pay stub in place of a Form W-2 to e-file. Arizona says this is not proper practice.

The stakes are real. In the mystery-shopping study, 4 of 25 returns obtained lacked the required PTIN, and Schedule C returns, the form most small owners use, were the most problematic area. Fabricated deductions produced refunds the taxpayer could later be asked to repay.

A small point on the PTIN itself: only individuals can hold one, and the annual fee was cut from $11 to $10 for applications and renewals filed on or after September 30, 2025. That fee is the preparer's cost, not something you pay separately.

Records to gather before your appointment

The IRS notes that good preparers ask to see your records and receipts so the return is accurate. A preparer who asks for nothing is a warning sign. Bring:

  • Last year's return, if you have it.
  • Every W-2 and 1099 you received, plus platform summaries for gig income.
  • A profit-and-loss summary or a list of income and expenses for the year, with receipts for larger items.
  • Mileage records if you drive for work.
  • Records of estimated tax payments you made.
  • Bank routing and account numbers for direct deposit.
  • Information on dependents and any childcare, education or health coverage forms.

You do not need to be perfect. A shoebox of receipts still gets sorted, but each hour of sorting is time you may pay for.

How the process should go, start to finish

Use this as your yardstick for any preparer.

  1. Intake conversation. You describe your work, income and family. The preparer confirms what they will prepare and the fee in advance.
  2. Records review. They look at your documents and ask about gaps, such as an expense with no receipt or a 1099 you were expecting.
  3. Income and deduction review. Income is confirmed, business expenses are sorted, and eligible deductions and credits are reviewed.
  4. Explanation of the finished return. You see what the return says and why, before you authorize anything.
  5. Authorization and e-file. You approve, the preparer signs with their PTIN, and the return is filed with your own bank details for any refund.
  6. A copy for your files. Keep it. You may need it for a loan, a lease or a letter from the IRS.

Step four is the one most often skipped, and it is the one that protects you. Because you are responsible for what is on the return, you should understand it before you approve it.

Working with Sally Sam Ventures

We prepare personal returns for W-2 employees, families, freelancers, gig workers and self-employed filers, and small-business returns once scope and fees are confirmed. You work directly with Samuel, who reviews your income and expenses, looks at deductions and credits, and explains the completed return before you authorize filing. You can meet locally in Auburndale and Polk County or work entirely online, and you get clear next steps at each stage.

If you are weighing a first conversation, book a time and tell us what kind of work you do. If you already have a return and want a second look, our tax review is the place to start. You can also see everything we prepare on our Auburndale tax preparation page.

Sallysamventures

What a good preparer gives you that software alone does not

Software asks questions in a fixed order. A person asks the question you did not know to answer. A freelancer who drove for a delivery app and also sold goods online may not realize those are two income streams with two sets of expenses. A family with a new baby, a job change and a side business has several things interacting at once. A preparer who sits with the whole picture can see the connections, and one who explains the result lets you make informed decisions for next year, such as setting aside money for estimated payments.

The National Taxpayer Advocate's 2026 Purple Book recommends the IRS be allowed to set minimum standards for federal tax return preparers and to revoke the identification numbers of sanctioned ones, noting most preparers are not credentialed. Until that changes, the checks above are your protection, and a preparer who welcomes them is usually one worth hiring.

FAQ

Should a small business hire a CPA, an enrolled agent or another preparer?

CPAs, enrolled agents and attorneys all have unlimited representation rights before the IRS. Other preparers have limited or no representation rights. Choose based on your situation and confirm the preparer's credentials and PTIN before sharing your records.

What is a reasonable price for small business tax preparation?

Prices vary widely, from $60 to $800 across the 53 visits in a 2026 mystery-shopping study. The fee should reflect the forms and time involved, be explained in advance and never be a percentage of your refund.

When should I hire a tax preparer for my business?

The IRS recommends choosing a preparer with a track record who is available year-round, since questions can come up months or years after filing. Starting before the filing season gives you time to organize records and ask your questions without a deadline pressing on you.

Do I need a preparer if I am a freelancer with a few 1099s?

You must report that income either way, and if your net self-employment earnings are $400 or more you also owe self-employment tax. A preparer helps make sure income is reported correctly and eligible expenses are not missed.

Can I work with a preparer remotely?

Yes. Many filers share documents and review the finished return online. We offer both local service in Polk County and virtual preparation.

Sallysamventures
Questions About Your Business Taxes?
Call to discuss personalized tax preparation for your small business and the support available in Auburndale and Polk County.

Sources

Created with BabyLoveGrowth to create better content